The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1

Truthfully, the title says it all, but it never hurts to reiterate. After much deliberation, Metal Review proudly presents The 100 Most Essential Heavy Metal Albums of the Decade.

The idea for this compilation emerged many months ago. Since then, a smattering of similar lists have sprung to life; but in the (presumed) haste to recap the decade, many of the resulting products have been--to put it mildly--less than comprehensive. Now, by no means are we declaring this list to be infallible. Lists never are, and that's part of their appeal. Our intentions were far simpler: to compile a retrospective that would not only celebrate the most impressive albums of the past ten years, but also to provide a versatile guide for enthusiasts that may be new to the genre.

Whittling this tome down to a svelte 100 entries was no easy task. Collectively, the MR Team nominated nearly 400 albums. After an arduous voting process to establish the top-ranked albums, it was then decided that each band would only be represented once. So, if you think (for whatever reason) that Soundtrack to Your Escape should've gotten the nod over Clayman, feel free to raise hell. 

And if you don't see your favorite album in this first post, hang tight. This is only the first edition in a series of ten. We've broken the list down into ten-album volumes, attempting to take a cross-section of the decade with each swipe. It's important to keep in mind that this is not a ranking of the "best albums of the decade." This is just a comprehensive collection of killer albums that every metalhead of the 00's should have in their library, and hopefully a solid jump-off point for the acquisition of at least 100 more.

Without further verbosity, we present the first ten essential works of heavy metal:

 

Morbid Angel - Gateways to AnnihilationMorbid Angel - Gateways to Annihilation

By the turn of the 21st century, most of the big golden-age death metal bands had ground to a creative halt. Not so for Morbid Angel. Though Trey Azagthoth, Pete Sandoval and the rest of MA’s rotating cast have explored varying degrees of dizzying speed throughout their storied career, Gateways to Annihilation delves deeper into their Lovecraftian ooze than ever before. A rich, full production, Steve Tucker’s savage vocal performance, and Azagthoth’s most alien soloing to date give Gateways an unearthly psychedelic bent that has yet to be replicated in the death metal world. [Earache, 2000]

 

 

 

In Flames - Clayman

In Flames’ stock had been steadily rising prior to the release of Clayman, and it turned out to be the album that elevated them to metal’s upper echelon. In turn, it jump-started the emergence of the melodic death metal style, which, ironically, the band would shift away from on subsequent albums. No less than four of Clayman’s tracks remain staples of the band’s live set, an impressive feat given their ever-expanding catalogue and a credit to the album’s enduring nature. [Nuclear Blast, 2000]

 

 

 

 

Behemoth - Zos Kia Cultus

While spending a majority of their early years either plying black metal or lurking beneath the shadow of fellow Polish warriors Vader, Behemoth exploded in 2002 with this death metal masterpiece and exposed a far larger audience to Nergal and his esoteric-yet-bombastic death metal. To this day, the album's monstrous title track and "As Above, So Below" stand as death metal personified. Now certified as international death metal superstars with three critically acclaimed albums under their belt, it was Zos Kia Cultus that truly opened the floodgates for Behemoth. [Avantgarde/Olympic, 2002]

 

 

 

Lamb of God As the Palaces Burn 

Before the so-called “New Wave of American Heavy Metal” became an image-obsessed caricature of itself, the redneck thrash machine known as Lamb of God dropped this little nuke. As the Palaces Burn is the sound of a band and musical movement at their most creative and unfucked-with, giving an entire new generation of thrashers their version of A Vulgar Display of Power in a package filled with groovy, beg-to-be-played thrash riffs and searing vocals courtesy of a man unstable enough to make them believable.  [Prosthetic, 2003]

 

 

 

YOB - The Illusion of Motion

YOB are living proof of the power of execution. Though they’ve never forged deep into new territory, their blend of classic doom grandeur, heady psychedelia, distinctive wailing vox, and masterful craftsmanship has earned them a well-deserved spot near the top of the doom genre. The Illusion of Motion, their third album, brought YOB to a far broader audience and established the mind-expanding yet skull-crushing formula that’s characterized each of their releases since. [Metal Blade, 2004]

 

 

 

 

PrimordialThe Gathering Wilderness

If ever a band perfectly captured and conveyed the concurrent frailty and power of the human spirit, Primordial did on The Gathering Wilderness.  Unmatched in its emotional intensity, this record’s Pagan black metal celebrates the power and beauty of the band’s native Ireland with the infusion of that country’s melodies and folklore.  Even as the album as a whole is crafted with dazzling skill, it is Nemtheanga's impassioned vocals that consistently astound; experience “The Coffin Ships” and know his pain. [Metal Blade, 2005]

 

 

 

All Shall Perish - The Price of Existence

Despite the praise heaped upon their Hate.Malice.Revenge debut, no one could have foreseen the impact that Oakland, CA's All Shall Perish would make with their sophomore effort. The Price of Existence all at once revitalized, redefined, and laid the deathcore genre to rest. As numerous imitators and countless pretenders make their way to the scene, The Price of Existence continues to stand as a landmark release that is unlikely to be equaled. [Nuclear Blast, 2006]

 

 

 

 

Neurosis - Given to the Rising

Neurosis aren’t the kind of band who can satisfy themselves with repetition, and much of their 21st century output reflects that restlessness. A Sun That Never Sets and The Eye of Every Storm exhibited a growing preference for desolate ambience over heaviness. Given to the Rising violently reversed that trend. Neurosis’ tenth studio album is a stunning recapitulation of the band’s storied past, blending many of their various approaches into a titanic blast of cosmic heaviness. Given to the Rising serves as a powerful reminder that the fathers of post-metal can still put their offspring to shame. [Neurot, 2007]

 

 

 

Withered - Folie Circulaire

It’s tough to crack through the thick, charred shell that encases this album, but when it’s finally broken, the reward is sickly cathartic. A devastating, cacophonous hybrid of nearly every extreme strain hurled forth in this decade—sludge, doom, and death, with a black-as-tar delivery—Folie Circulaire encapsulates a seething hatred that is primed to spill forth into the decade to come. A violently textured harbinger for a forthcoming societal implosion, and the sonic manifestation of the wreckage to be left in its wake. [Prosthetic, 2008]

 

 

 

Napalm Death - Time Waits For No Slave

Riding a creative upswing in the new millennium, British grindcore innovators Napalm Death released Time Waits For No Slave nearly twenty-five years after their first record, and they’re still as pissed-off as ever.  (Hell, maybe even more so…) Stripping back some of the more progressive additions to earlier albums, Time gets back to modern Napalm doing what modern Napalm does best: raging solid, with Embury and Harris’ razor-sharp death/grind riffs beneath Barney’s inimitable bellow. Violent, vicious, unflinching, unfailing, brutal and brilliant. [Century Media, 2009]

 

 

 

Ninety albums left. See you next week...


Posted 10-02-2009 11:16 AM by Rev

Comments

SlayerM wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 6:58 AM

Wow. I LOVE this idea. It seems like a lot of work too. Great job MR. Looking forward to all ten volumes.

ex-inferis wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 7:51 AM

Gayman? I dunno....

PachLGV wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 7:57 AM

Bravo!! Bravo!! Tks for the huge undertaking. But you better mention somewhere in the countdown Equilibrium's "Sagas", or I'll raise hell

hougie wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 10:54 AM

Nice, guys!!  Great idea... and albums.

DeathMetalJesus wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 12:29 PM

This is an awesome idea, I can't wait for the further editions.

ragnarok wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 1:16 PM

all shall perish?

DeathMetalJesus wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 1:29 PM

Definitely All Shall Perish. You never know though - Iron Thrones might get a spot too ;).

The Metal Mallet wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 1:53 PM

Definitely look forward to seeing the next batch of entries.

theblade wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 2:46 PM

Well, I love the idea for this.  It is kind of hard to judge or give much input at this point w/o seeing the rest of the list.  Time Waits for No Slave is a great album, but are we gonna see other ND albums on here that are more deserving IMO?  Looking forward to the finished product.

eminor wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 2:51 PM

Nope, only one album per band.  This was a pretty controversial issue, actually.  In the end, the album that got the nod was the one on which consensus was reached most quickly.  Even with 100 spots to fill, there was a lot of arm wrestling over the final list.  I think as the weeks go by people will agree that although it's easy to argue that other albums should be there, it's hard to dispute the quality of the onces that made the cut.

stoned to death wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 3:25 PM

I like that its one album per band. Makes for a versatile list. Unlike most lists, I'm sure the one here will be much more valid and mostly contain bands that deserve to be there. This will be fun!

theblade wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 3:36 PM

Yeah, I dig the fact that it on only one album per band.

tanknitrous wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 5:44 PM

This is awesome! Can't wait for the rest!

DeathHead wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 7:32 PM

I like this idea! It's sure to turn me on to some new sounds, and I'm curious to see how much I agree/disagree with the selections.

Matt McMadden wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 9:02 PM

This is a great idea, guys. Looking forward to the rest of 'em.

flah wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 9:16 PM

Interesting.

MikeHBB wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 9:48 PM

this is a sick idea

morbid angel is great

same with all shall perish

im looking forward to the rest of the volumes =]

ll2ene wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-19-2009 10:08 PM

Thankyou very much for this and just i cant wait fdor the arguments to start. I wonder if Angel Dust will be there.

lee wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 5:10 AM

I like the idea guys and look forward to checking out all of them. VERY NICE to see Clayman on there. It is a great album and should have been the start of a new from of Heavy Metal but instead they only did it that one time and went to crap  shortly there after (although R2R is a good album). I still play Clayman constantly and have for like the last 7 or 8 years or so. It is just that good.

Anyways, look forward to reading more, I haven't a lot of the albums though on this first go around.

gordeth wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 8:03 AM

It's nice to see Gateways getting some love. I think it's one of MA's best albums but it seems to be the most overlooked in their discography.

Blackgaze wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 9:34 AM

interesting recommandations, especially that Primordial record that could be good for me. Still, i didnt did that Neurosis record......as i don't dig Neurosis at all :P

fightingmike wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 4:29 PM

I agree with all of those except Withered and All Shall Perish.  

Fatal_88 wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 7:21 PM

Great idea !!

I have very different opinions on each album but except for Primordial and YOB but great work nonetheless.

powerade wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-20-2009 8:44 PM

You guys should make an altenate 100 after you finish this one. Great idea though. I wonder if Psycroptic will get in. There is bands that are certainties like Opeth and Mastodon. The ones that get left out will be just as interesting

SlayerM wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 1:12 AM

Jeeez, putting just one Opeth album is gonna be tough. I have to look into that All Shall Perish.

Wharwulf wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 5:17 AM

Nice work guys. Gonna have to check out the Primordial and the Withered. Didn't much care for the All Shall Perish but have enjoyed the hell out of the rest.

Rev wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 6:21 AM

@ powerade:

An "alternate" 100 isn't going to happen. If it were, we would've just called the list 'The 200 Most Essential Albums of the Decade,' and that would've been total overkill.

The Devil Himself wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 8:44 AM

If it's 1 album per band, and Time Waits for No Slave made it over Enemy of the Music Business, Order of the Leetch or even Smear Campaign, it's a fucking joke.

Rocco wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 1:41 PM

For those who haven't yet checked out Primordial, listen to the aforementioned TGW and then listen to To The Nameless Dead which I find to be their better album.

ellipsis wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-21-2009 6:44 PM

Definitely a good idea. And really? That ND album came out this year? It feels so much longer than that...

Stu wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-22-2009 3:03 AM

Awesome feature. Now I know where to start for the mountain of bands i'm yet to check out.

Definitely chose the  right Neurosis and LOG albums.

Besty wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-22-2009 2:33 PM

Look forward to the other 90. I only have 4 of those, so like Stu, I'll be checking out the ones that I don't have.

Thanks guys

steeler wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-22-2009 11:18 PM

none of this albums are ESSENTIAL for me,,,i'll wait next week

slaytanic1 wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-23-2009 5:41 AM

Hmmm, a great idea and a list that`s bound to split opinions! I have to say I hardly even like any of that list ( All Shall Perish?? Lamb of God?? Essential??!! ) and there are better Napalm albums IMO but it`s sure to be an interesting read.

DeathMetalJesus wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-23-2009 5:42 AM

I just realised, I only have 3 of those albums, and 5 of the others are practically essential... This list is gonna end up costing me some money I think...

mst wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-23-2009 6:34 PM

The first three are right at their place, but Lamb Of God or All Shall That Perished? Is the 100 most essential albums of the decade a marketing trip or what?

Anyway, interesting idea.

I'll just hope that you'll get better than a thirty percent grade next volume (yes I know, given me the grader, that could be a feat!).

eminor wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-23-2009 7:27 PM

Ah, what the fuck.  Sure, maybe you don't dig LoG or All Shall Perish.  But Primordial?  Yob? Napalm Death?  Neurosis?  You're telling me they're not outstanding?

mst wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-23-2009 8:45 PM

eminor, I admit that Primordial is a group which has fallen off my radar for too many years, Napalm Death is just too, let say, coarse for me and Neurosis, too pretentious.....

stoned to death wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-24-2009 11:42 AM

The only disagreement I have with the list is that Time Waits For No Slave got on instead of Enemy of the Music Business. I was surprised but I'm not complaining. Also, I was really excited to see that Morbid Angel album on the list. Cheers to that.

I_KILL_YOU_LOL wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-24-2009 9:08 PM

i love lists like these. looking forward to the rest and seeing Nevermore's This Godless Endeavor on there

Trezevant wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. I
on 10-25-2009 7:52 AM

Even if you don't like Lamb of God or All Shall Perish, you can't argue that their respective albums were watershed moments for two major stylistic movements this decade (NWOAHM and deathcore). That's what makes them essential.

DolphinDude31 wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1
on 10-26-2009 1:55 PM

Very happy to see Withered on there.  I thought they would have been forgotten about after last year, but apparently not.

Wyrd wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1
on 10-29-2009 11:30 AM

While some of those are enjoyable, personally none are essential.  Be interesting to see what else crops up.

Wanderer wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1
on 11-02-2009 3:36 PM

Props for including the Behemoth and Morbid Angel albums. I'm going to question Napalm Death's Time though, it does absolutely nothing for me and there were a lot better ND albums in this decade alone.

republicofthedead wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1
on 11-25-2009 11:13 PM

i freakin love that gateways to annihilation is on here thats easily the best album on here tons of great songs!!

Jishwa wrote re: The 100 Most Essential Albums of the Decade: Vol. 1
on 12-20-2009 9:35 AM

No way Illusion of Motion is better than Catharsis or The Unreal Never Lived.